Yoko Ono is the owner of a watch given to her by John Lennon
Published: Thursday, Nov 14th 2024, 14:40
Back to Live Feed
Yoko Ono is the fully entitled owner of a watch given to John Lennon two months before his murder. The Federal Supreme Court has rejected an appeal by a collector against a decision by the Geneva judiciary in 2023.
The collector had acquired the watch ten years ago in Germany. For the Federal Court, there is no doubt that Yoko Ono, the widow of the ex-Beatle after his murder on December 8, 1980 by Mark David Chapman, is the heir to the watch.
In its ruling, the Geneva court found that the watch had been stolen by one of Yoko Ono's former chauffeurs. There was no indication that the Japanese artist Yoko Ono could have given the chauffeur such a personal object from her husband.
As the watch had been stolen, the Federal Supreme Court ruled that the collector could not have legally obtained possession of it. According to the German law applicable in the specific case, the good faith of the buyer also plays no role, according to the ruling published on Friday.
The watch, a Patek Philippe chronograph with moon phase display, was purchased in New York in 1980. Yoko Ono had the words engraved on the back: "(JUST LIKE) STARTING OVER LOVE YOKO 10-9-1980 N.Y.C". She gave the watch to John Lennon on October 9, 1980 for his 40th birthday.
After the murder, the watch was kept in Yoko Ono's apartment. It was listed in the musician's estate. It later came into the hands of the man who had been Ono's chauffeur between 1995 and 2005.
The watch was handed over to a German auction house for sale by a third party. The complainant bought it there in 2014 and then had it valued by a Geneva auction house.
When Ono found out about this, she did not know that the watch was no longer in her possession. When the collector filed a lawsuit to establish ownership, the artist resisted. The Geneva court of first instance and later the High Court of the Canton of Geneva found that Yoko Ono was the only legitimate owner. (Judgment 5A_520/2023 of September 13, 2024)
©Keystone/SDA
English 
German 
French 
Spanish 
Arabic